I remember from my last role as a campus Chief Advancement Officer the tabletop exercises we engaged in to prepare for the possibility of various types of campus crisis emergencies. We were all “actors” playing out a manufactured campus emergency. Fortunately, I never had to jump into action on any real emergencies for which I had rehearsed, but I was prepared. Unfortunately, on a weekly basis we are reading about crisis after crisis on college and university campuses from coast to coast.
When a crisis unfolds at a college or university, the first questions the institution should consider are about its people–students, faculty and staff. The questions of “Who is most affected?”, “What support do they need?”, “What details do we know, and what series of actions will take next?” are the crucial next steps when crisis occurs.
However, for the advancement office, other questions follow close behind: How might this crisis be viewed by our donors? How do we sustain our relationships with our donors, best inform our donors and not make the crisis about fundraising?
Advancement’s role is not to protect gift revenue at all costs or put a positive spin on a damaging or painful situation. Advancement’s role is to help the institution communicate with as much transparency as possible, honesty and integrity, listen with a caring ear, and maintain the trust that has already been developed with those donors, so it doesn’t have to be rebuilt.
Whether the issue involves campus safety as has been the case in recent campus homecoming events, financial uncertainty, which is a more common storyline than ever, or controversy over an institutional decision, advancement should always be included and part of the campus response.
Start with people, not pipeline
Alumni, donors, parents, and volunteers are more than audiences to be managed. They are members of your campus community, and their concerns matter and may be personal. An alumna may be worried about students on campus, especially if the alumna is also a parent of one of those students. A donor may want to understand if the crisis impacts a program they support. A volunteer may be fielding questions they do not know how to answer and need a consistent, university response.
The first response should be to acknowledge those concerns, not pivot immediately to institutional reputation or campaign momentum. And this should go without saying but attention should not be reserved for the largest donors. Personal outreach may differ by relationship and need, but access to accurate information should not depend on giving capacity. In a crisis, empathy is not a preamble to the “real” message, it is part of the message.
One set of facts, many conversations
Advancement should be at the crisis planning table before an urgent donor call forces the issue. The Advancement office’s contribution should be practical: identifying constituent concerns, flagging upcoming events and solicitations, and helping leadership anticipate the questions people with long-standing relationships may ask.
That does not make every gift officer a spokesperson but rather, all having the same consistent messaging and response to likely questions. Institutional communications should coordinate public messaging, with leadership, legal counsel, and other responsible offices informing the response. Advancement should translate approved messages into appropriate relationship-based conversations and not improvise explanations or promise outcomes.
The facts are the facts and should remain consistent even when the delivery differs. A public statement, an alumni email, and a personal call, may all serve different purposes but should not convey different stories. A personal relationship is not permission to share confidential information, offer privileged assurances, or speculate about an investigation.
When answers are incomplete, a useful response is straightforward: “Here is what we can share and confirm”, “Here is what remains unresolved” and “Here is where updates will be shared.” Candor about uncertainty is better than confidence that cannot be supported by your institution.
Prepare the team before the phones ring
In my introduction, I shared the example of the tabletop exercises. Those exercises helped to prepare the campus community before an actual crisis occurred. The crisis tabletop exercises were much more than acting out a crisis scenario. There was also the important role played by the communications team of providing the institution and the advancement team with more than simply a statement to forward. Additionally, the communications team provided consistent messaging on how to respond, where to direct difficult questions, and of utmost importance–what not to say.
If I had to build a simple readiness checklist it would be around these essentials:
- A clear point of contact: Who approves updates and handles questions the team cannot answer?
- Shared talking points: What is confirmed, what is not, and which information must remain confidential?
- A thoughtful outreach sequence: Who needs direct contact because of their connection to the situation—not simply the size of their gift?
- A review of scheduled activity: Which solicitations, celebrations, social posts, and events need to pause, change or include messaging about the crisis event?
- A listening and follow-up process: How will concerns reach institutional leaders, and who will close the loop?
I would also include regularly scheduled tabletop exercises covering different types of crisis scenarios because practice matters. A tabletop exercise can test whether the team knows how to handle a distressed parent, an angry volunteer, or a donor asking for information that cannot be disclosed. The goal is not a perfect script. It is a shared understanding of responsibilities and boundaries. There should also be debrief after the exercise to assess what went well and what areas of the practice need to be improved.
Listen without letting money dictate the response
If an institution is faced with an actual crisis, advancement can offer leadership a valuable listening channel. What questions keep recurring? Where is an explanation unclear? Which concerns suggest that the institution has not yet properly addressed the impact of the crisis on its community? These themes must be brought forward accurately, including criticism. However, keep in mind that listening must be distinguished from surrendering institutional judgment. A donor’s concern deserves attention; a donor’s financial leverage should not determine the facts, the outcome of an investigation, or the institution’s obligations to students, faculty and staff.
If a supporter threatens to withhold a gift, the response should be respectful and clear: acknowledge the concern, explain what can be shared, and arrange appropriate follow-up. Do not bargain over institutional values or make commitments outside your level of authority.
Stewardship continues – even when asking pauses
I would not treat every crisis as a reason to stop all advancement activity. I would treat it as a reason to review that activity carefully. An automated appeal or celebratory campaign announcement may be inappropriate while the community is processing harm or uncertainty.
Stewardship, however, can remain essential. Supporters may need accurate information about a scholarship, a restricted fund, or a program’s future. If an answer is not yet available, say so and establish a follow-up rather than offering reassurance the institution cannot substantiate.
If fundraising is part of the response—for example, an approved effort to meet an identified student or campus need—it should have a clear purpose, transparent use of funds, and appropriate safeguards. It should never turn people’s suffering into a campaign device.
Rebuilding trust is the work after the statement
A statement is not the finish line. Advancement should help sustain communication as the institution carries out its commitments: sharing verified progress, acknowledging unresolved concerns, and reconnecting people with the mission without pretending the crisis never happened.
For me, the test is not simply whether giving resumes. It is whether people receive honest answers, whether promised follow-up happens, and whether institutional actions match institutional words.
The advancement office cannot communicate its way around a failure of leadership or accountability. But it can help ensure that the people who care deeply about the institution are heard, informed, and treated with respect.
If I were a campus Chief Advancement Officer that is the lens I would bring to crisis communications: not protecting the next gift but earning the trust that makes a lasting relationship and many next gifts possible.
Media Inquiries: Patrick Taylor, 59Media, patricktaylor0103@gmail.com, (917) 653-4785

